Oliva double robusto
double robusto 5x54. I like an Oliva and have smoked a number of their lines and vitolas. This is the best one yet! Engaging smooth sweetness with solid tobacco flavors from light to finger-blistering nub. Stack-a-boxesworthy. Review by Alex M on 3/16/2026Black swan nub a dud
Bought a five pack. First cigar no real flavor until last third an even then not much to talk about. Just finished my second five day after my first didn’t burn well lots. More flavor than the first but not very enjoyable. I’m a big oliva guy. I love all that I have tried but this size just isn’t working for me I won’t be buying again Review by William on 12/27/2025Excellent if it’s not plugged
I love this cigar! But it seems like it’s 50/50 getting a good one from a plugged one. These are so creamy and chocolatey when you get one with a good draw. But I have have bad luck with getting ones I can’t get a decent draw. These remind me a a smore. Review by Dave on 12/20/2025Excellent Stogie
One Of My Favorite Sticks Review by Darryl on 12/8/2025Very good
This is a great cigar. It’s flavorful but not overpowering. Great draw and smooth. Taste like an expensive full bodied cigar. But man this is smooth. Little bite that keeps you honest about a black swan. This is a favorite that keeps you wanting more. Opulence, decadence and rich. Lucky to have one to review. Review by Greg on 11/1/2025Wowwer maddy
This is an outstanding Maduro! Rich and creamy with intense cocoa notes, undertones of spices and nuts....highly recommend trying. Top notch construction, one of the best Maduros I have smoked in a while. Review by Mike on 8/16/2025Flavorful smoke
Tons of transitions from chocolate, leather, sweet tobacco, coconut, and graham cracker. Definitely worth getting a 5 pack of these. Review by Josh on 8/15/2025Awesome Stogie
You Definitely Can't Go Wrong With This Stick It Has A Beautiful Profile And Well Balanced Taste Throughout Review by Darryl on 4/13/2025Exceptional Cigar
This cigar was a surprise. I’ve seen these advertised, but was cautious because of my disappointment in other brands that produced a “Black Swan” version. Oliva did not disappoint. This is an exceptional cigar for the price point. Flavorful, well constructed, and complex. Tasting notes: dark chocolate, espresso, white pepper, a hint of smoke paprika on the retro in the 2nd third. Do yourself a favor, ours has a selection for yourself. Cheers Review by Chillgar on 1/24/2025It's an Autumn weekend in the North East!
Born, raised, and live in NE Ohio. Oliva's newest cigar brings back wholesome memories of burning the leaves after a day of raking all those Fall leaves, hayrides at the pumpkin patch, caramel and chocolate treats from the farm market, and the bonfire with cider after the Sectional football game your home team just won.
In my own personal opinion, one word: "Nostalgic"
Shortly after the first draws, the flavors announce themselves, then settling into a creamy blend of what other reviewers are spot on about. Any "complexity" is weak enough to stay in the background in order to savor the most relevant of what you love, and pick to enjoy.
On a personal note, it's not "peppery" to me, except maybe to describe the strength of the woodsy, savory, turned Autumn leaves burning.☺️ Review by Barry Post on 11/24/2024Great Smoke
Super smooth Review by JEFFERY on 11/5/2024Black swan greatness
I love these Black Swans. Got one from a friend and had to have more. One of my favorites! Review by Jonathan on 9/9/2024Affordable excellence
Other reviews and description are spot on. Review by Geoffrey on 7/8/2024Very nice
I agree with most here.....incredibly smooth and creamy for a full flavored Maduro! Yes, the construction is perfect, as is the burn. There is a choco- cocoa flavor note, but not in your face. It's not very complex, but that's a good thing personally, I think the series V is better, but this cigar is a strong second. Review by Gstand on 6/21/2024One of Oliva’s Finest
This is proof that Oliva can push out new, excellent blends. Everything about this cigar is beautiful, including the damn box. It will be difficult for the Black Swan line to follow up this cigar. Buy them while you can. Review by Sam on 2/20/2024Oliva Black Swan Toro
This cigar is very tasty with smooth creamy smoke. The cigar burns well without having to touch up and is packed with flavor. Review by Todd on 1/9/2024Very nice
I like this cigar. Draw is perfect and I like the flavor. Honestly tastes more like something from My Father than Oliva. Definitely the highlight of the sampler it came in so far. Review by Andrew on 12/22/2023Black Swan swoon
I'm not gonna get all technical and delve into all kinds of overbearing dissections of their flavor profile...what I will say is this cigar is the ultimate smoke I have found yet. And I've been smoking cigars for more than 50 years. Chocolate, baked spice(sorta) and the "musty/musky" flavor that I absolutely love. Cains have it, this just has it so much more. Oliva makes fantastic cigars, this is their finest, IMHO!!!! Review by Carey on 12/21/2023Oliva Black Swan
strong cigar,creamy spice, pepper... Review by irakli on 8/5/2023Absolutely fantastic cigar!
Absolutely fantastic cigar! I’ve had three or four so far and they have all been perfect. I also picked up on the pine. I think it’s a delicious cigar and I hope to pick up a box when they’re in stock. Thank you for doing what you do! It’s great when a retailer has such a passion for the product. This and the Free Will series are some of my absolute favorites. Keep up the fantastic work. Review by Chris_K4CGB on 8/1/2023FANTASTIC
"I'm already on my 2nd box. This cigar is a FANTASTIC value! The flavour profile is quite reminiscent of a Liga No. 9. Good luck finding that anywhere else. I feel like I should order a pallet of these before everyone catches on." Review by mwgallotte1 on 7/27/2023Grand Slam
I'm a 40 year daily cigar smoker.... Cigar Page working with Oliva has been a match made in heaven IMO. .... When the Black Swan hit, I grabbed a bunch of samplers simply because anything Oliva makes in Maduro, I'm a fan of. The wrapper on the Black Swan, just like Alex said here is really special. In addition to all the flavor qualities, it's a great looking wrapper. It's got a very evenly mottled look which tells me this one was aged to perfection. Again, a bit of aging on the Black Swan did wonders. I bought a fair amount of them right outta the gate. I aged them a bit and then when I started smoking them, I unknowingly went through my entire supply way too fast. If the Free Will was a home run, the Black Swan is a Grand Slam IMHO. If you like Oliva cigars, you're most likely going to truly enjoy the Black Swan. Review by bearpaw1486 on 7/14/2023Surprised to say the least!
Initially, on first light, peppery and spicy retrohale mixed with dark sweetness. Very pleasing.
First third: these black swans have a very distinctive taste. Like nothing else. Lightly peppered and baking spices, but with a heavy dark sweetness. Like a dark chocolate spicy bomb. Earthiness is also present. Cedar undertones.
Second third: starts off almost the same as the first third. Only now, everything is balancing out. Extremely pleasant and complex. There is now a maple or caramel type sweetness happening. Cannot complain about this cigar at all.
Final third: much of the same only not so much pepper or spice. Sweetness is now more pronounced and absolutely delicious.
8.5/10.
Review by CHARLES ST.H on 7/5/2023Oliva Black Swan
Strong barnyard
Strong natural sweet tobacco
Strong barnyard
Medium grape soda
1/3:
Strong baking spices
Strong natural dark sweet tobacco
Light astringency
Medium citrus
Strong floral
Light cream
Light cedar
2/3:
Strong baking spices
Strong natural dark sweet tobacco
Light astringency
Medium citrus
Strong floral
Light cream
Light cedar
Strong dark chocolate
Strong medium roast coffee
3/3:
Strong baking spices
Strong natural dark sweet tobacco
Light astringency
Medium citrus
Light floral
Light cream
Light cedar
Strong dark chocolate
Strong dark roast coffee
Strong bourbon
Light to strong pepper Review by Crux on 6/26/2023In a class of it's own
This does not smoke or taste like any Oliva I've ever tried and I have a humidor filled with different Oliva's.
I've ordered once more and if they hold out with order again. I'm told they are even better with a couple of years aged. I fully intend to find out.
If they can manage to keep them in production and keep the price this reasonable this one will take off like a rocket. Review by Terrywhite on 6/20/2023Excellent
This is one of the finest cigars i've smoked for the price. I bought a box of the Toros and I'm going to be sad when they're gone. Review by James on 6/2/2023Great Value Will Buy Again
Had to wait a bit for this smoke but it didn't disappoint. The wrapper was one of the things Oliva does the best. Excellent construction, lots of smoke and flavor all for a few pennies over $6/stick. I bought the the 6x60's and will be re-ording. My only comment that could be helpful to others might be that this smoke was on the more medium side of medium-full. I know, we're getting into individual palates and preferences but the strengtho meter showed full and I think it falls a bit short of that. It's not my fav Melanio Maduro, but it;s a fraction of the price and worth every penny. Review by David K on 6/2/2023TASTY
GREAT ! Very Flavorfull ; Smooth , Winner !!. Review by James on 5/24/2023El cisne de Oliva
This is the first Oliva I'll be buying again. Just as described by CP. An overall delight! Well deserved name - a rarity among Olivas. Review by Vinzogar on 5/10/2023
Write Your Own Review
Only registered users can write reviews. Please, log in or register