Very good for the price point
Took a chance on this when it was on sale and was very surprised. It has a razor-sharp burn and a great flavor. It will be my daily smoke going forward. Review by Stephen on 5/27/2026homerun
Just as amazing as the reviews claim! I'm absolutely ordering more.
Flavor profile hits like a mix between a Brickhouse maduro and an Oliva. Review by cigarbrute on 5/26/2026Double Maduro Nicaraguan Box-Pressed Double Robusto
Product description is accurate. Decent 60 minute burn. Starts peppery then slides into smooth maduro espresso cocoa mode. Occasional touch up on some but most burn even. Would recommend. Review by R on 2/23/2026Nice Stick ' For Everyday
Cigar Lovers Of The World Unite ' These Stogies Are For Whenever You Just Wanna Lite-Up For Any Occasion I 100% Recommend 100% Review by Darryl on 2/21/2026A Delicious
It's Definitely Bang For The Buck ' I Just Had To Give It Another Review Review by Darryl on 11/18/2025Double Maduro Torpedo
I was apprehensive to pay the price for an unbanded cigar but, it had such good reviews. The only complaint is they seem to plug in the last 3rd. Other than tat, great cigar. I will buy more. Review by Kevin on 11/8/2025A Very Delicious Stick 100%
I Was Directly Blown Away This Product Is Awesome with Taste And Balance I Actually Think It's Oliva For The Better Part Look It Just Doesn't Get Any Better Than This. Review by Darryl on 11/7/2025Gordo
"Even" is the best way I can describe it.
Not much in the way of complexity, but spice forward from start to finish.
It burned cleanly, requiring minimal touch ups, but also a little faster than I thought it would (just over an hour)
Review by Jalal on 5/30/2025Double Maduro Nicaraguan Box-Pressed Robusto
If you're looking to not blow through your good smoke's. This is a good cigar, for the money, burn is a little uneven, but it scratches the itch if you don't want to blow through the good stuff in your humidor. Review by Irishwolfhound on 5/27/2025Pretty good stick
After reading some of these negative reviews, I wonder if we are discussing the same sticks. Mine are well constructed, burn evenly with great flavors all the way thru. The wrapper is a dark with a nice oily sheen. Texture on this wrapper is like a fine leather invisible seams and very minimal veins. Sure, its not a "special occasion" smoke but its as good as some $10 ones. Review by stephen on 4/12/2025The weight is disappointing.
The vitola I bought is BP Toro Grande (6.5' X 54).
The flavor is definitely better than expected.
Not too much spice and cacao, earthy, woody.
Medium to medium+ body and strength.
Good smoke output.
But it burns rather quickly.
Also, the flavor starts to break down sharply from about halfway through the entire length.
(It's like the flavor in the very end starts slowly in the middle.)
The draw is good, but the ash retention is weak.
These shortcomings seem to be caused by the underfilled filler.
When I touch the cigar, it feels soft overall.
When I weigh it on the scale, the cigar is light.
It's 10+% lighter than similar sized cigars.
In fact, the cigar is cheap and the flavor is good, so my opinion may be harsh.
But this is Cigar Page. Cigar Page has a lot of great Cigar promotions at great prices.
If this cigar were a little more solid and heavy, it would be a great cigar. Review by Jung on 8/29/2024Great Cigars
I love the Double Maduro BP Nicaraguan mazo! (it smokes like something AJ Fernandez would roll by the way) ";)" Review by Bob on 3/4/2024By the way
I like them now, and will have no problem buying more Review by Ryan on 3/1/2024The more I smoke
The more I smoke the better they seem I did get a couple with a soil taste but I’ve since cut and cold drew almost all of them and that was just a couple 4 out of 5 I’ve smoked now were stellar for the price I’ve decided I just may purchase these again Review by Ryan on 2/29/2024So/So
Some taste good others give you a taste of ACTUAL soil in your mouth overall would not purchase again Review by Ryan on 2/28/2024A Great Smoke
I purchased these cigars because of the video. Boy was he right. What a great smoke, I only had maybe 2 that was tight rolled. But thats not going to stop me from ordering them again. Review by SmokingBlackNeck24 on 12/1/2023Not sure about this one
Looking at the reviews, I must have gotten a bad batch....granted, mine have only had about 2 weeks of humidor time, but I've had (tried to have) 5 of the Rothschild size that I got. 2 of the 5 were actuality pretty good. Hopefully more humidor time will help. Review by Mike on 8/27/2023My new everyday cigar
I bought the rothschilds a few months back and was impressed at how good they were. Legit good, not just for the price good. Last month I bought 2 bundles in the rothschild size and 1 In toro. The toro sized sticks were rolled tighter and were just ok but I burned through almost all of the smaller size and just bought 5 more bundles to keep on hand. I have hundreds of pricey premium cigars in my humidor but find myself reaching for these often. Perfect cigar for a quick 35-45 minute smoke at any time of the day, great draw, plenty of tasty smoke, medium body and an unbelievable price. I can smoke a few of these a day without feeling guilty about the cost. If these continue to remain consistent, they will always have a spot in my humidor. Review by Sean on 7/28/2023I am happy!
Greta cigars by all means, great price, ordered 10 bundles... Love it Review by Roman on 7/22/2023Very nice surprise.
Bought bundles of the 5.5 x 52 robusto (sold as box pressed, wasn't) and the double robusto 5.5 x 55 (sold as box pressed, is). One week humi time after receiving - stunned at how good the robusto was. Nice sweet surprise, mild first 1/3, medium 2/3 - 3/3, 75 minute smoke time. Vanilla and butterscotch, very little pepper, very good construction, draw & burn if a little soft. Will definitely buy again, great anytime of day cigar esp. w/ a bourbon rocks or dessert. Review by Fred on 6/19/2023Winner
Lived up to everything in the written description and then some.
I got the Rothschild and just smoked my third one, no humi time was necessary.
A full hour of enjoyment smoking this shorty.
Will most definitely buy again. Review by Brian D on 2/4/2023Well worth it.
I do wish there was more consistency stick to stick... can be hit or miss. However, when they hit, they hit hard and when they miss, they don't miss by much. These are my new daily smoke. I just need to whittle down my humidor before I have room for more. Review by Robert on 12/1/2022So far, not good..
Maybe these need humidor time, but right out of the box, bunched too tight, draws like a wooden dow pin,. Flavor is not as described, not deep and dark like a maduro should be, very bland flavors. Blind folded, you wouldn't even know it is a maduro, at least the way maduros are supposed to be. I will give these a few weeks or months in the humidor, but I am not optimistic they will improve their flavor, especially the too tight, poor draw. At press time, would not buy again. Review by David on 8/17/2022Killer sticks!
I recently bought some Oliva seconds and they were very inconsistent as far as flavor and construction goes. These on the other hand…AMAZING! I just got them in Thursday and have already smoked 4 of them. Mind you, I have close to 200 sticks in the humidor all of them being brand name(some high end brands). These however, are a new staple on the shelf. Pick some up and I promise you won’t be disappointed. Thanks Cigar Page! Review by Mike on 6/12/2022The Churchill
First, let me say I've been buying cigars from CP at least once a week since June, 2021. There are some good online sources for cigars and I've investigated several of the well respected, top rated ones. CP is hands down the BEST I've dealt with! Great price, good product AND, FREE SHIPPING! All that makes CP pretty unbeatable in my view. I know, high praise. I am NOT a shill if yer wonderng. Just a fan who understands the retail game and CP has earned my loyalty. On to the cigar....
I'm primarily a Maduro fan.There are quite a few really good ones regardless of cost – budget or otherwise. Some others, not so much. I smoke and enjoy my cigars with a boubon or coffee in the company of good friends about every Saturday night.This is certainly one the good ones! Definitely worth trying. As with other sticks I enjoy, I'll be coming back for more of these. ENJOY! Review by Bob on 6/4/2022Nice Maduro
Bought a pack of twenty and I’ve almost run through them. Had one of these the other night and then an Aging Room Quattro and I’m not going to go as far as to say they were to that level but a great cigar at an excellent price, and that’s why I’ll give it a 5. Slight hint of cocoa, leather, peppery but not too strong. I’ll be ordering another 20 pack. Not all overruns get a good review from me, I’m about to go put a two star on another product. Give this one a try instead! Review by Garrett on 8/9/2021wow
Awesome smoke for a stick with no band on them Review by Les on 6/3/2021Excellent all over
Bought these on a whim along with a box of fancy band label and I prefer these hands down. Not as tight a roll as some, but easy to smoke at a relaxed pace. Good medium-full flavor. Normal go-tos are CAO brazilia, VSG's, Aroma de Cuba's and these are 95% of those. New staple in the humidor. Review by Greg on 11/18/2020The real deal
Cigarpage hit the jackpot with these babies. The flavor, burn, construction - it smokes like a $8-10 cigar and perfect for any occasion. From the golf course to relaxing with a single malt scotch and everything in between. This is a must try. Review by Ray Z on 10/21/2020
Write Your Own Review
Only registered users can write reviews. Please, log in or register